Dead Poet Society – Monarch

Every now and then, an album lands on the desks at Zware Metalen that makes you wonder just how much heavy metal it actually contains. Dead Poet Society bring one of those odd ducks. Alternative rock, electronics, garage rock, crushing riffs and even hip-hop beats: Monarch throws all of it into the mix. So anyone climbing aboard had better strap themselves in. Going straight doesn’t seem to rank very high on this American quartet’s list of priorities.

Monarch is Dead Poet Society’s third album and follows FISSION two years later. For the production, the band brought in Mutemath’s Paul Meany, who has previously worked with the likes of Twenty One Pilots and Pierce The Veil. His job wasn’t to change the band, but rather to help them get closer to the essence of Dead Poet Society. The result is an album on which boundaries seem to exist mainly so they can be crossed as quickly as possible.

And that starts before the roller coaster wagon has even properly left the station. Hollywood On Fire opens with a genuine a cappella passage, giving Jack Underkofler’s distinctive high-pitched voice all the room it needs. Then the hulking guitars crash in and, without further warning, we’re sent hurtling down the first drop. The song is theatrical, decidedly over the top and anything but an easy introduction. But why start cautiously? The riff is deliciously heavy and immediately pours a thick sauce over an album that otherwise has little intention of sticking to metal conventions.

Roach continues along the same lines, although the production feels a little too excessive here. A distorted beat, deliberately bored-sounding vocals and sudden bursts of heavy guitar constantly bounce off one another. It feels like a musical game of table tennis in which Dead Poet Society prefer to hit the ball in a different direction every single time. Just when you think you understand the rhythm, the band changes the rules.

Sinner Systems then demonstrates that this odd duck can bite pretty damn hard as well. The overdriven riffs are almost constantly present, making this one of the heaviest songs on Monarch. Especially live, this could be one of those tracks that completely knocks you off your feet. After all those twists and turns, Lost suddenly feels strangely familiar. It is lighter, more accessible and, above all, much more straightforward in its construction. There is actual structure. On another album that probably wouldn’t even be worth mentioning, but here a stretch of straight track suddenly feels like a welcome change.

Then comes the highlight of the album for me. Cold shows just how good Dead Poet Society can be when all their ideas are heading in the same direction. The song is compelling, the chorus settles into your head almost immediately and the melody works without sanding down the sharper edges. When Underkofler finally opens his throat completely, singing along at full volume behind the wheel (or pretty much anywhere else) becomes almost unavoidable. Here, experimentation, accessibility and heaviness find each other without getting in each other’s way.

On Dead On The Inside, the bass guitar takes centre stage. The filthy, enormously fat bassline is pushed right to the front while the band once again experiments freely with rhythm and dynamics. It is impressive how many ideas the quartet manages to cram into its music, but slowly another question begins to emerge: did every single one of those ideas really need to end up on the album?

That doubt grows stronger with Miami For The Weekend. Suddenly we find ourselves in something resembling a garage rock song, naturally supplied with a strange Dead Poet Society twist. It raises an interesting question. Are we listening to a band that genuinely couldn’t care less about genre boundaries and simply does whatever it feels like? Or have Dead Poet Society lost sight somewhere along the way of what they actually want to sound like? The answer probably lies somewhere between those two extremes.

The strangest carriage in the entire attraction is called The Park. A hip-hop beat, a dark atmosphere and uncomfortable-sounding guitars once again create an entirely different experience. By this point, it hardly comes as a surprise that Dead Poet Society decide to move the rails while we’re still riding them. The Art Of Suffering eventually brings the ride to a close in fairly melodramatic fashion. And when the carriage finally rolls back into the station, confusion is what remains above all else.

Even after several listens, I’m still not entirely sure what to make of this record. Monarch reminds me of X2, the now-closed attraction at Six Flags Magic Mountain. It wasn’t enough for the track itself to throw you in every possible direction, the seats could rotate during the ride as well. The result was an experience in which you sometimes barely knew which way was up. Monarch regularly feels exactly like that.

I can easily imagine some listeners wanting to get straight back in line once the ride is over. Dead Poet Society take risks, experiment freely and couldn’t care less about the borders between genres. Scattered throughout the album are also moments that are downright brilliant. Cold is the best example, while the riffs in Hollywood On Fire and Sinner Systems make it perfectly clear that this odd duck can indeed get seriously heavy. But a roller coaster that tries to surprise you from its first metre to its last can also become exhausting. Sometimes I don’t want another loop, corkscrew, free fall or seat suddenly spinning backwards. Sometimes I just want to go straight for a while.

Score:

65/100

Label:

Spinefarm Records, 2026

Tracklisting:

  1. Hollywood On Fire
  2. Roach
  3. Die If You Don’t
  4. Sinner Systems
  5. Lost
  6. Cold
  7. Psalm 136
  8. Dead On The Inside
  9. Miami For The Weekend
  10. Get Hot
  11. The Park
  12. The Art Of Suffering

Line-up:

  • Jack Underkofler – Vocals, guitar, keyboards
  • Jack Collins – Guitar, vocals, drumprogramming, keyboards
  • Dylan Brenner – Bassguitar, guitar
  • Will Goodroad – Drums

Links: